Thursday 27 November 2014

Do you stand your ground or run away?

Hi! I shall begin this piece by starting on my friend Alvin Tan's Facebook page - now as you may know, Alvin is now in Los Angeles and there was a discussion about the possibility of facing racism in America. There was this Malaysian guy who was paranoid about it - he posted a question. "Perhaps you have not faced racism yet, but what if you are just walking down the street and someone shouts racist abuse at you, like if he says some really nasty racist insults to you - then what will you do?" My reply was, "I would turn to face him, look him or her in the eye and shout something equally abusive back at him, the fool had picked the wrong guy to mess with. Please grow a set of balls, you may enjoy having them." My response surprised that Malaysian guy - because he thought that our response to such an incident would be to run home crying and then return to Singapore. He didn't anticipate my response to be as such and I suppose part of the reason why I would respond like that was because of my experiences growing up in Singapore.
Have you ever confronted anyone instead of running away?

Now in the eyes of this Malaysian, getting verbally abused when simply walking down the street in Los Angeles or London is a scary thing and maybe he has never ever experienced anything like that in Malaysia; that is why the spectre of racism is so scary for him. However, I have been through national service in Singapore. I have personally been bullied in the army, I have seen my fellow Singaporean soldiers being treated extremely poorly and all this whilst we are supposedly making this noble sacrifice to serve our country. I have seen my fellow soldiers being bullied for their ethnicity, their weight, their looks, their mannerisms, their sexuality, their social class, their religion, their accents, their political beliefs, the way they talk, the way they walk, the way they work - you name it, I have seen plenty of Singaporeans treating other Singaporeans really badly during NS. 

In the real world, we all know that simply staying in the country or city of your birth does not automatically protect you from bad people who will be nasty to you, exploit you, bully you and attack you. Rather than worry about crazy strangers attacking you of nowhere, perhaps you should be more wary of friends, family members, neighbours and colleagues. Heck, for me, as I was physically abused by my mother (she had serious psychological issues and anger management problems), I never ever felt that there was any "safe place" for me in this world free from any kind of external threat since I never even felt safe in my own house (ironically, I felt safer in the streets or at school then at home as a child). Instead, from a young age, I learned to cope with the threats that may come my way in life. 
Do you know where the real threats in your life may come from?

Allow me to share a little story from my childhood, this happened when I was about 6. On the street where I lived, one neighbour had a really huge dog that was always on a leash. One day, as I was walking down the road, to my horror, I saw this dog just standing in the middle of the road and I quickly calculated what I could do - there was no way I could outrun the dog and the dog was about 10 meters away. The dog was staring right at me and was walking closer and closer to me. I panic and froze - then my savior came along: one of the neighbour's Filipino maids appeared out of nowhere. "Please help me." I whispered to her. Calmly, she took my hand and we walked towards the dog. She stood tall and strong, staring right back at the dog. "Come, don't be scared, walk with me," she said. The dog simply stood still and let us pass - she then told me, "just be calm if that happens again. Never run away. If you run away, then the dog will know you are scared of it and will chase you down and bite you. But if you show the dog that you are bigger and stronger and you're not afraid, then you will be fine, okay? 

So that was how it was for me, learnt from this kind Filipino lady how I should respond the next time a threat came my way in life. Stand your ground, never run away, face your threat bravely and show them you are not afraid. I remember how in school, there were the kids who used to run to the teacher for every little dispute or complaint they may have with other students. "Teacher teacher, he scold me, he touch my bag etc." Oh the number of inane complaints my primary school teachers had to put up with. The naive kids who ran away to the teacher, expecting the teacher to solve their problems rather than try to solve their own disputes. Okay, perhaps children may encounter more complex disputes they simply cannot solve on their own - but the bulk of these disputes could have been resolved if the children simply took the time to try to talk to each other about their differences. No, instead our standard default response seems to be to run away from the problem and to find someone else to solve the problem for us.
I am quite good with dogs today actually.

Now that is wrong. That is so wrong and it must change. I realized this in the army when we were pretty much expected to solve our own problems - we were supposed to be adults (well, we were barely 18) but still expected to behave like responsible adults rather than little kids. Often there was no one to run to and we had to learn to get along with people we didn't like, work with people we despise and often had to live with people with could barely tolerate. Running away simply wasn't an option in many of these cases - no, we were simply forced to work out our differences, learn the art of compromise and hiding our feelings. It was where I was introduced to office politics: it was good training for the real world that awaited me out there.

Oh the amount of shit I had to put up with in the army, the number of very difficult people I had to work with - well, I survived it all and lived to tell the stories. So that did train me to face my problems and try to solve them, rather than run away and cry. It saddens me that the Malaysian guy in question didn't even think about confronting the racist in the situation - after all, if someone has already hurled abuse at me, my first reaction would be to turn around and give as good as I got because I would be angry that he had the audacity to insult me. Anger would be my primary response and anger would make me stay and stand my ground - not run away. Running away doesn't solve or change anything.
NS is a good training ground for the crap we have to face in the real world.

Have I ever done so? Well I have never faced a random racist attack before but there was an incident once at work when two people made a racist joke and I reported them. I made sure they were threatened with dismissal and it was only with my consent that they were allowed to continue with their contract. I guess this is one thing my regular readers will know about me - I don't get mad, I get even. Well, okay, I get angry first, then I get even. Anger is a great motivator. Perhaps some of you who are pacifists would advice me against allowing anger to overwhelm me at times like this - but what is the alternative? Run away and cry to my mother? Oh, you forgot, I spent most of my childhood running away from my mother. So that was never an option for me. 

Don't get me wrong - when I was in the army, I may have gotten angry on many occasions, but it was often the art of compromise that helped me achieve an amicable solution. My arny unit was full of "Hokkien pengs" (ie. Mandarin and Hokkien speaking soldiers who did not have either a poly diploma or A levels) and sure, there were conflicts which could have not been resolved by fist fights. A lot of it depended on the other party - sometimes you had to make friends with your enemy (keep your friends close and your enemies closer) and sometimes I had to show them that it was a very bad idea to mess with me. I always chose the best response to make the best of a difficult situation. I have seen people in the army attempt the 'run away and cry' response: they can't help it, they just don't know how to response otherwise to a difficult situation. There is really no where to run, so they end up isolated, helpless and miserable. It is not like they didn't have the resources to try to solve their problems, but I'm afraid there is something in our culture that conditions people to run away when confronted with a difficult situation. Now this has got to change: running away should never be your default response to any and every problem you may encounter in life.
It's kinda strange how the difficulties I faced as a child and during NS has actually taught me some of the most valuable lessons in my life - now I am not an angry person who goes around life picking fights, on the contrary, I am very rational and pragmatic. I have always preached the value of picking one's battles. But in this case, I am talking about when trouble comes looking for you: 不是我找的麻烦,是麻烦来找我 - thus we have to consider a range of responses including standing our ground and facing our problems instead of just running away.

So that's it from me on this issue - what would you do if some stranger started insulting you in the street? Would you turn around and face your abuser or would you run home crying to your mother? What do you think should be the right response then? Please let me know what you think - do leave a comment below, many thanks for reading.

9 comments:

  1. For me, it will always depend on situation. As you had said, we have to choose our battle.

    In a situation where it is the mafia or gangster who insult me, I will just walk away. the same situation is applied if we are insulted by people in the villagers that we pass by instead of the city.

    I will not threat the running away as a losing option. Instead it will help us to avoid a bigger incident such as body injury by the other party towards us. The same is true when we are tourist in a foreign country. This is even more true for the ladies when they are being insulted by the uncivilized men where if they stood their ground, chance of rape may also happen.

    Like your phase a lot "Pick your battle.".

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hmmmm. Kelvin, why are you always defaulting to the worst case scenario? I have stood my ground and face people like that before - whilst I have not been attacked for my ethnicity/skin colour, I have been attacked for being a cyclist. Let me give you an example.

      Once I was cycling home, minding my own business when a bunch of dumb kids jump out in front of me to scare me, hoping to maybe make me crash. I stopped in time, got off my bike and confronted the kids (who were like what, 15, 16 years old)? And as they realized that they had picked the wrong cyclist to mess with, one of them suddenly turned and ran away and one by one, they followed the first guy who ran away.

      So before you run away, turn and look your attacker in the eye. Is it a scary mafia wielding a gun or is it a bunch of dumb kids who may turn out to be afraid of you? Heck, it was just me vs 4 of them and they were the ones who turned and ran away because I am brave enough to stand my ground and confront them. There was no violence, just words exchanged.

      I'm sorry to have to say this but you sound like a coward - I do pick my battles but you seem pretty desperate to justify running away from a difficult/troublesome situation when I have demonstrated in my piece that in some cases, such as when I was in the army, there is simply no alternative but to face the problem at hand and try to make the best of a bad situation. It could be messy, it could be tricky but running away would not solve or change anything.

      If you want to use my phrase "pick your battles" - then that involves first getting information, analyzing the situation and deciding what the best course of action is: whether it is to stay and deal with the abuser or to run. I dislike the way you seem to use my phrase "pick your battles" to justify running away - no please do NOT take that phrase out of context to justify being a coward with no balls.

      Please understand that picking your battles means sometimes going to war and fighting a battle - it is not a blanket excuse for you to turn and run home to your mother crying like a scared pathetic loser of a coward every time you are confronted with a problem.

      Furthermore, I think the Malaysian is totally salah in worrying about random attacks from strangers when really, we should worry far more about attacks from people we know: friends, colleagues, family members and neighbours. And when I am confronted by someone like that who is giving me trouble, I never run away from the problem.

      Kelvin Tan, don't be a coward, grow a pair of balls for crying out aloud. You're a man, aren't you?

      Delete
    2. I had stood on my ground before which is related with your "Week 7 racist joke incident".

      When I was in secondary 2 (All boys' school), I was molested by a guy in class. He touched on my private part. My first reaction is beating him and shouting at him. Unfortunately, being a guys who was always being bullied in class (From 9 years old to 15 years old), that did not stop him at all. Instead I was being molested for 2 more times. I just be patient by ignoring him and act as if nothing had happen while my heart is burning with anger.

      When the teacher enter into the class, I straight away went forward and complain to her.

      To cut the story short, I was being confront not just by the molester's classmate, I was also being harass by the gangster's group as I had cause quite a number of students being called up for the molest incident where other students in secondary 2 students are involved in the molesting activities.

      Other than that, I almost went into coma for doing the right thing during my secondary 3 school for doing the right thing where a classmate of mine hit my head very hard with a roll up newspaper. Usually, people will just avoid the hit but for me, I just stood there and let him hit my head.

      Standing on my ground sometimes bring me nowhere. In my first job, I try to stand on my ground on things such as trying to get a pay with payslip, my overtime pay, getting my pay on time in front of my manager or the boss of an SME company (Family business). I work on a 6 days' week and 1 day work more than 12 hours with only basic pay and transport allowance (need to sign on blank cheque). I even went to Ministry of Manpower (MOM) in Singapore to complain and all these come to a naught. All they said is that they can only help me claim overtime pay only.

      So, the question here is whether there will be a good or bad consequences if we either sand on the ground or run away. We will need to weight on both action. There is another action where we can just back away and fight back in another day.

      Delete
    3. OK let me respond to the few points you have made.

      1. With regards to your secondary school incident, you didn't understand what I meant at all. I understand that what you went through was unpleasant, but you ran to the teacher. Perhaps that was one of the most natural reactions for you - but the way to have stopped it altogether was to have stood up to your bully and showed him that you were tougher than him (ref: what the Filipino maid told me about the dog). You ran to the teacher, that's the same as running away. In doing so, you showed that you were weak, you were a great victim and it was an open invitation or others to continue bullying you. I'm sorry to have to be the one to point this out to you, but whilst I do not condone what the bullies did to you at all, your reaction was wrong. You didn't stand up to your bully, you ran away. And that only prolonged your suffering.

      You didn't react correctly. Perhaps it is somewhat harsh of me to judge you at the age of 14/15 but it would have been better for you to have tried to put up some kind of resistance to the bully rather than simply allowed him to have his wicked way with you.

      Sometimes it is all about being able to live with myself. It's like when those dumb kids tried to scare me off my bike by jumping out in front of me - if I didn't confront them, what if they tried to do it to someone else who may fall down and then seriously hurt themselves? Also, I couldn't live with myself if I let those kids get away with it, part of me wanted to punish them and scare them away - and I did just that. It gave me a sense of satisfaction to have been able to face up to them - I can then look myself in the mirror and say, "yeah, nobody messes with Limpeh. I'm a Chao Ah Beng bad ass motherfucker so you guys had better run away, fast."

      Will standing your ground to fight always yield the results we want? No. But I don't think I can live with myself if I allowed myself to run away. I wouldn't respect myself - I would hate myself if I allowed myself to act like a coward. So it is not a question of whether or not there will be good or bad consequences, but more the point that nothing can be solved by running away - so we may as well try to stand our ground and make the best of a bad situation.

      Delete
  2. I agree that if the other person had a weapon or is a known mafia, I would just walk away and certainly report to the police. At the very least, there will be a record of the incident should anything happen to me. Other than that, I will stand my ground. No one messes with me or my family. This happened a few days ago, Stupid alpha male kid at school bullied my son by deleting all his work on the school ipad. Don't ask me how he could do that because that is another issue the school has to fix. My son was upset and reported it to the teacher. He had to leave school early for tennis, so he could not redo his work. Teacher made the stupid alpha male kid redo my son's work. When my son told me the story, I was fuming, and I wanted to call up the stupid alpha male kid's mother to yell. My son told me he would handle it. I had to let him handle it because I can't fight his battles forever. The next day, after my son took it up with the stupid alpha male kid and hashed it out, he said he felt good. The world is made up of the likes of this stupid alpha male kid. And many of these stupid alpha male kids are in my son's class. Such is life. Just don't mess with my child.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well done for letting your child fight his own battles - it's called growing up. You're a good mom :)

      Delete
    2. Thanks, Alex. It took a lot of restraint on my part not to call the stupid alpha male kid's mom who happens to be an alpha ... (hmmm ... where did the kid's alpha-ness come from?) and vent to the teacher as well. I figured my son's lesson in standing up to bullies was more important than my own desire for vengeance. I tell you, some days I don't know what I am doing as a mom, but I just wing it.

      Delete
    3. Well Di, I think that you did the right thing because you showed your son that you care and were ready to jump in and help should he be unable to deal with the situation. And to his credit, he knew how to handle the situation. Good for him too.

      Delete
  3. Figure out if it matters enough to you. If it doesn't, shrug and walk away. If it does, push back hard. And once you do push back, don't ever stop til you've got what you want.

    ReplyDelete