Thursday 23 June 2016

The EU referendum exposing the cracks in British society

Hi guys. Some of you may have seen my video on the EU referendum but I thought I'd do a blog piece as well. In case I haven't made my feelings clear enough, I am very pro-EU and of course I am going to vote to the remain in the EU. Regrettably though, the referendum has brought out the very worst in British society and it has been deeply divisive. At the moment, it does look like we are going to vote to remain by a very slim majority, but a lot of it will depend on voter turn out on the day itself and either way it goes, it is going to be very close indeed. But then again, if British society was unanimous about the issue, then there wouldn't be a need for a referendum - the fact that there is no consensus on the issue allows us to put it to a vote and get a result which will seal the fate on the issue for at least a few decades. It enables us to say, "we voted, that's the result, so just accept it, that's the end of the matter, let's get on with life, okay?"
I thought it was a pretty bad idea to put this to a referendum in the first place because I don't trust the people of the UK to make the right choice on this issue. That is the problem with democracy, everyone gets a vote - including stupid people. They get a say, no matter how uninformed and ignorant they may be. The UK's membership of the EU is a very complex issue and there are valid reasons for both sides of the argument - however, it got ugly pretty quickly and the leave side focused on immigration and xenophobia. The EU became the scapegoat for all things wrong with the UK and leaving the EU was marketed as a magic solution that would somehow solve all the things that have gone wrong in the country. (Yeah, right.) A lot of the unemployed people moaning about "all the immigrants, coming over here, taking our jobs" have scarcely taken a moment to look in the mirror and ask themselves why they cannot get a job. Even if you kick out all the Eastern European migrant workers, these people are still pretty much uneducated and unskilled - now the issue would then be for the government to help these people acquire the right kinds of skills to be able to get a decent job; the UK's membership of the EU is pretty much a red herring. Do we have problems in the UK? You bet we do. Would leaving the EU solve anything? No, it wouldn't - it would just make things far worse.

You can argue till the cows come home - but people will vote the way they want to and many poorer, older, working class British folks will vote to leave the EU. I have had so many arguments on Facebook with the friends of my friends who want to leave the EU - one even said this, "I know leaving the EU will wreck the British economy, but I've got so little to lose and I'm so fed up with the system. If I can make the rich people suffer with me this way, then that will give me some satisfaction, that's why I am voting to leave." Good grief. I tried but I couldn't reason with him - I told him that if he hated rich people that much, he may as well become a suicide bomber and blow himself up in some fancy Mayfair restaurant. As soon as I wrote that, I thought, oh shit, have I gone too far - was that joke in really bad taste? Then he replied, "yeah, I might just do that. I fucking hate rich people." Oh dear. Such is the politics of envy in the UK.
But as horrific as that analogy may sound, it is actually pretty apt when you think about it. After all, during a suicide bombing, the person most likely to die in the process is the suicide bomber himself/herself - others may be killed or injured in the process, but it cannot happen without the suicide bomber taking the full brunt of the explosion. Likewise in the UK, the people most likely to vote for Brexit are those who are older, working class, uneducated, unskilled and poor - these are the people who are going to be hardest hit should the UK leave the EU. Why are they willing to literally take the full brunt of the explosion just to make a point then? Such behaviour defies logic: stock phrases like "turkeys voting for Christmas" and "cutting off your nose to spite your face" have been used a lot. I doubt the glee of showing just how xenophobic and anti-immigration they are cannot possibly outweigh the hardship they will face should Brexit happens. This has been dubbed a 'working class revolution' by some - but let me explain what is really going on.

This part of the story just gets uglier and uglier. Suicide bombers are often brainwashed - they believe they are dying for a just cause and they will go directly to heaven when they die, where 72 virgins await them there. Now the right wing press in the UK have been misleading their readers on so many basic facts about the referendum - anyone who is educated enough can see through their poorly written articles, but here's the problem and it is a very British one: the educated middle and upper classes read a certain kind of newspaper and the uneducated working class read trashy tabloids full of football news and semi-naked women. There is more soft-core porn than actual news in a lot of these papers and the readers of the newspapers are not educated enough to question what they read in these tabloids; heck they are barely literate and believe every word they read in there. The right wing politicians know that such voters are the easiest to deceive and manipulate, so they promise these people the equivalent of 72 virgins: that the UK would become stronger and better should we leave the EU. This is when politics does get very ugly because we have seen so much deceit, lies, manipulation - particularly when it comes to the least educated section of our society. We recoil in horror when a young, uneducated teenager is brainwashed to become a suicide bomber, yet we somehow accept it when the working classes are brainwashed and duped by the right wing press? Oh I am equally disgusted.
The UK is a very divided society but somehow, we have muddled along all these years without any major strife despite the status quo persisting all these years. Rich people send their children to expensive private schools where their children will grow up mixing with the children of other rich children. It is only at university where they may encounter some working class folks who have battled against the odds to earn a place at university, but even if they may sit in the same tutorial or lecture at university and exchange polite greetings, they are hardly going to hang out together by choice outside the learning environment. Once they graduate, the rich kids will go on to get good jobs thanks to their superior education (hey, money can buy you a better class of education) and their parents' connections and even if they do have working class colleagues, they may at best exchange polite greetings if they happen to work in the same office or sit across the table from them at the meetings, but again, they would rarely ever socialize with each other outside the context of work. These people would rarely live in the same areas and thus the rich would tend to socialize only with their other rich friends. This pattern reinforces itself over the years, decades and centuries.

The poor on the other hand would send their children to state schools where their classmates would be the children of other poor parents. Even if they work hard and get a place at a good university, they still lack the family connections to help them get a good job as easily as the rich kids. The odds are so stacked against them in every step of the way that social mobility is a huge problem in the UK. In my humble opinion, it is much easier for kids from working class backgrounds in Singapore to succeed and get good jobs because the concept of social class is far less rigid in Singapore than the UK. Without a referendum exposing the deep divisions in our society, people just get on with life, As long as there's food on the table, people have jobs to go to, the schools do a decent job in educating the children, no one will talk about some kind of class war or social revolution as long as they are distracted enough by the latest reality TV contest show or some celebrity scandal. The EU referendum however, has brought up so many very ugly feelings as neither side of the social divide want the other side to decide their fate for them when it comes to the EU.
This reminds me of my experience serving national service back in Singapore - I served a grand total of 2 years 4 months national service in Singapore back in the 1990s before I moved to the UK. I had to work alongside people from all social backgrounds whilst in the army: it was an interesting social experiment. I was once asked by a British person if this would foster better social cohesion in Singapore: after all, being forced to live and work alongside each other like that would expose you to people from different social backgrounds. His assumption was that we would all enjoy working with each other and the shared experience would somehow make us bond as friends. I had to tell him that his vision was somewhat idealistic: I learnt to keep my head down and stay out of trouble, but that was not the same as liking the people around me. At best, I silently tolerated having to work with people I had nothing in common with - at times, I resented their presence but kept my mouth shut since there was little I could do about it. I did make some good friends whilst in the army, but they were only with people who had a very similar social background. Don't get me wrong, I managed to get along with people from very different social backgrounds whilst serving in the army, but none of those working relationships never turned into real friendships outside the army camp.

As for me, I don't like the idea of any kind of event like a referendum creating more disharmony and discord in what is already a very divided society. Let's not kid ourselves over the issue - British people tend to be rather polite, but that politeness is but a veneer which covers up the cracks in our society and that decorum is not going to hold our society together in times of crisis. The pro-leave campaign has become extremely nasty and xenophobic and the pro-stay campaign has totally vilified the pro-leave camp for their bigotry and xenophobia. The two sides hate each other as the campaign has reached its climax in the final days. But after all the votes have been cast tomorrow and the polling booths finally close, regardless of the outcome, these two sides who currently hate each other have got to find a way to get along. Oh dear. Can we rely on British politeness and decorum to come to the rescue, after such an event has exposed just how divided we are as a society? Or will this lead to a more fundamental change in our society, as we shrug our shoulders and say, "who are we trying to kid?" I think people will try to go back to the way things were and some may even pretend that nothing has changed, but I think something fundamental has already changed for us.
So that's it from me on this issue. I am going to vote in the morning and we shall know the results of the referendum by very early Friday morning, UK time. Many have said it is too close to call and I am rather nervous. But really, it has gotten to the stage when I just can't wait to get the darn thing over and done with as I have had enough of the bitter squabbling, the horrible lies told by the leave campaign and I don't need to be reminded just how many uneducated, xenophobic, ignorant idiots there are in this country. I work hard and earn a lot of money just so I can have high walls around me, to shield myself from people like that in London. My fingers are crossed for now, many thanks for reading.

27 comments:

  1. Let us just hope that there are enough votes to offset those by the foolish.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's an IQ test for the nation!

      But seriously, I don't think we've ever thought about how many people are rich, affluent and well educated vs those who are poor, unskilled and uneducated. Such statistics are considered .... un-PC I suppose. This referendum will be the closest we can get to such a test (though there will always be exceptions on both sides).

      Delete
  2. Hello Limpeh,

    I understand your point of view - political ambitions and personal gain can lead some people to foster their fellow countrymen's worst gut feelings.

    On the other hand, I feel we should admit the EU has done a great job of turning itself into the perfect scapegoat - for example, its treatment of Greece has left many people disgusted.

    I think the Bremain camp can only hope for people to be too afraid of those right-wing hardliners...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Grazie Andrea. I am going to go to the polling station now and vote :)

      Delete
  3. I am for Britain to remain, based on whatever limited knowledge and stake I have. For one is better for the economy, and I am generally against xenophobia and anti-immigration driven causes. I think the world has gotten a lot smaller and will continue to do so, and trying to go against that is not only small minded but in the long run not practical. I believe come tomorrow, Britain will remain, as I think there are more stakeholders, jobs, businesses, etc that would prefer to stay in the EU.

    Having said that, I think its a tad casual to dismiss such democracy and the purpose of a referendum so easily. After all, in Singapore we'd have close to zero chance of such a choice being put to the public. And if many of you dismiss our democracy as something that pales in comparison to western democracies, then referendums like Brexit come as part and parcel of what such ideals entail. Even, if there is the off chance it will not go your way.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Raymond, thanks for your comment. On my way home from work today, I saw a taxi with a big "vote leave" sticker on it. I wanted to cycle up to it at the lights and shout something like "I voted to remain in the EU!" But as I got close to the taxi and looked inside - good grief. The taxi driver was this scary looking fat guy covered in tattoos. Yikes. I wonder how many passenger will feel safe riding in his taxi. Anyway, I immediately changed my mind, kept my distance and kept my mouth shut. Such is the problem with democratic ideals - you wanna give people like that scary looking tattooed taxi driver a say as well? Seriously? Oh dear.

      Delete
    2. I was just checking the live results. Too bloody close to call.

      Anyway, if one is for a status quo vote like what the British Government is, which is to remain, they should make the voting compulsory. That way they capture the 5-10% of people who really couldn't be bothered to vote, but have to do so. Inevitably, these people go with the status quo. They really have no strong conviction about politics and so on, plus they see David Cameron on TV, hear about Jo Cox's murder, etc. This bloc will likely mostly vote Remain and it will effectively seal the deal.

      In fact, in Singapore, compulsory voting is one very strong reason why the PAP has secured huge majorities time and again. Because they basically have in the bag that 10% of people who really show up to vote just because its compulsory.

      Delete
    3. Well, it has happened. I can imagine your frustration. I am as well on seeing my investments skydive, but that's the market for you. There will be a rise again, but for those who cannot reverse the decision and have to live with it in Britain, I hope they get what they asked for in terms of jobs, living and social security.

      Delete
    4. Every citizen has a right to have a say in his/her own country. While he may not agree to your opinions,he may not look ideally to your benchmark, not as educated as you, who are we to be condescending to another? Do unto others what you want them do to you.

      Delete
    5. Well, I woke up very early to see the results, hoping to just get the good news and go back to sleep for some hours. But no, I've been up since very early watching the news in utter total disbelief. I don't actually have that much cash on me right now, I do have a mortgage to service and the bulk of my investments are in property. No one is quite sure what is going to happen on that front: I am reading this at the moment http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-36537906 and it is not clear what will happen to interest rates - the talk of house prices falling are muddled to say the least. Some house prices will fall - but again, that really depends on location, location, location. The property market in a country as big as the UK has always been very complex. At least at this stage, I am glad I didn't put my money on the stock market but on the property market, so I am shielded from the worst of the impact of Brexit.

      As for interest rates (I have a mortgage on my 5th property), it is again, unclear what will happen. The falling pound will make imports expensive, so inflation will rise as a direct result, causing interest rates to rise, right? But then again, as costs for landlords go up, rents are expected to go up as well, so I may be able to collect more rent on my properties. So will it cancel each other out? Or wait, if there is a severe shock to the British economy (well, if today is anything to go by), the Bank of England might have to consider a cut in rates. In which case, the cost of lending could actually fall. It might leave rates as they are. In short, nobody is certain what the hell is gonna happen. It could be terrible, it could be the same - we don't know. My trip to America this summer is gonna be expensive though as the pound takes a hit against the USD.

      Delete
  4. How about the other point of view? How would EU suffer without UK? Considering now that London is the financial HQ of EU, how would they do without easy access to it?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The UK needs the EU more than the EU needs the UK. We're not the only rich country in the EU - there are plenty more. London would be hit very hard as it would diminish as the financial capital of Europe; people in the EU would turn instead to Paris, Frankfurt and Amsterdam to replace London.

      But it won't come to that. We will vote to stay. By a slim margin, but all we need is one vote over 50%.

      Delete
    2. You are probably going to be shocked then since BBC forecasts UK to leave. http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-36615028

      Delete
    3. They voted to leave. Anyway, I think the Brits will do well on their own. If Singapore could do it, and we were much worse off then, the UK has got more brains and talent any time to keep it strong.

      You may have stupid people voting this time. But the dumbest of all are those who think the UK cannot prosper further in a post-EU era.

      Delete
    4. @Choaniki - there is a talk of the London bubble. There are about 14 million of us in the capital who voted overwhelmingly to remain in the UK vs the rest of England and Wales who voted overwhelmingly to leave. In the end, it was enough to tip the balance 52%-48% and all I can say is that my friends on FB are saying that us living in the London bubble are so totally out of touch with the rest of the country (and that's part of the reason why they want to use this to send us a message that they are a force to be reckoned with). Civil war would be a nice thought, some of us are talking about London leaving England. As in, screw you idiots in the countryside, we're forming our own city state like Hong Kong and Singapore. We don't need you idiots.

      @Oliverchew I don't think it's a question of UK prospering post-EU, it's just a question of which path is easier, which path is better. The rational person would take the path that is better for the economy. In the end, it boiled down to immigration. When the Syrian refugee crisis happened, I knew this may have a severe impact on the outcome of the EU ref and it did happen. The referendum was always going to be about 'all this immigrants, coming here to take our jobs, put a strain on our public services'. It's not just about Polish plumbers and Hungarian electricians, but many Brits were fearful when they saw the way Germany and Sweden took in so many Syrians and they clearly didn't want to offer the same kind of sanctuary to Syrian refugees. Brexit will give the post-Cameron government any excuse to say no to more refugees. The short-term impact is going to be painful, let's just move on and hope that things get better soon.

      Delete
  5. Looks like Brexit is happening. Scottish separatist sentiment may arise again in ensuing months.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And I hope they get what they want. An independent Scotland!

      Delete
    2. And North Ireland appears to be contemplating that thought too.

      Delete
    3. That issue is addressed here: http://limpehft.blogspot.co.uk/2016/06/oh-shit-brexit-oh-shit-its-brexshit.html

      Delete
  6. I was surprised but it seems that UK really chose to brexit...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am totally shocked and dumbfounded as are my friends on FB. Then again, we are living in the London bubble - we are accused to being totally out of touch with the rest of the country. London voted overwhelmingly to stay in the EU whilst the rest of England and Wales voted overwhelmingly to leave.

      Delete
    2. I despair Sandra, I truly do. Like I said in my follow up http://limpehft.blogspot.co.uk/2016/06/oh-shit-brexit-oh-shit-its-brexshit.html I have met well-informed, intelligent teenagers who know a lot more about the issue but can't get a vote as they are under 18, but some adults who know nothing get a vote just because they are over 18? It makes no sense at all.

      Delete
  7. I am suprised by the result - to say the least.

    Also, I think Scotland and Northern Ireland won't accept it without a fight: Breexiters may be glad to destroy the EU... but they may end up breaking up the UK, as well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hope Scotland and NI get their independence. They are better off without England. Scotland really should have voted to leave the UK the last time. I hope they get the right result the second time round.

      Delete
  8. I think the bigger news now is that David Cameron is leaving by Oct and likely to be replaced by Boris Johnson. What a disaster that would be.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Guys, the follow up, post-Brexit article is ready here http://limpehft.blogspot.co.uk/2016/06/oh-shit-brexit-oh-shit-its-brexshit.html

    ReplyDelete