So whilst I was in Singapore, I went with my parents to visit an elderly relative. My mother tried to explain to this relative what job I did in England and she totally misrepresented the whole situation so badly. Like she wasn't even close. Okay, I really don't give a shit what this relative thinks I do in England, but I was really upset by the way my mother's summary of my career was so wide of the mark... it was one of those moments when I was so aghast I was lost for words. How can my own mother not know what I do for a living? Does she not take an interest in her own son?
| My mother doesn't understand how I balance two careers (yes it's me in the photo) |
I do call my parents up a few times a month to tell them what I get up you and they usually listen patiently as I give them details of what I do career-wise, especially since I am working concurrently in two very different industries. My mother usually doesn't say much in response apart from things like, "that sounds good" or "will that keep you busy?" You know, fairly generic responses. Never once did she say, "I don't understand" or anything to indicate that she totally doesn't get what I do. It was only when I witnessed that conversation she had with our relative that it dawned on me that my mother really doesn't understand what I do for a living at all - and that hurts.
Why does it hurt so bad? It is because if she doesn't know or understand what I do for a living, she wouldn't be able to appreciate what I have achieved so far. By that token, how could she possibly be proud of me, if she doesn't know/understand what I have achieved? Gosh, sometimes I do feel that my regular blog readers actually understand me than my own parents. Maybe there's still a small part of me somewhere that still craves her approval, but now I realized I can't get it because she is an old woman who doesn't understand what goes on in the modern world. Now that sucks - knowing that your mother can't be proud of you no matter what you achieve unless she can understand it on her terms and my mother is a retired primary school teacher who has totally lost touch with the modern world.
![]() |
| Do all children naturally crave their parents' approval? |
This is why she is so obsessed with caring for my autistic nephew who is ten years old - you see, she knows her way around a PSLE syllabus as a retired teacher, so she has no problems taking charge of the situation when it comes to my nephew. (Don't get me wrong - she does a good job of it.) She takes such a keen interest and can monitor every aspect of his education - whereas in my case, I don't know if she is simply completely disinterested in what the hell I do or if she has tried but cannot understand. Why didn't she ever say "I don't understand what you're saying"? Or has she forgotten everything I've told her? I don't know, it got me very depressed.
I spoke to my two sisters and they were like, "what were you expecting lah, aiyoh. She has no idea what the hell we do either, how do you expect her to understand what you do when she is an old woman? Have you forgotten how old she is?" One of my sisters is head of social media at her organization (she has a big stack of Wired magazines in her room) and my mother isn't on the internet at all, she has no idea what social media is, doesn't know what Facebook or Twitter is and can barely use a mobile phone. Needless to say, my mother also has no clue what my sister does at work. Same situation with my other sister and they just accept that my mother is an old woman who will not understand certain things and they just accept the way things are - and they told me to accept things I can't change.
I suppose my parents can understand really straight forward jobs, especially if it existed in the 1970s or 1980s - Tom is a pilot, he flies a plane for Singapore Airlines. Meiying is a nurse, she works at Tan Tock Seng hospital. Ahmad is a chef, he cooks at this restaurant in Bukit Timah. Indira is a seamstress, she makes beautiful dresses for women. Mrs Goh is a cashier, she works at the local supermarket. Mr Ang cooks and sells Bak Kut Teh at the hawker centre in Ang Mo Kio. Anything more complex or modern, they will struggle to comprehend.
So there you go, I have parents who do not know what I do for a living. Isn't it ironic, don't you think? I have two pushy Singaporean parents who ruthlessly bludgeoned me through the Singaporean education to produce a triple scholar whose academic record was every Singaporean parents' wet dream (I must credit writer Tan Hwee Hwee with that quote - you must read her books) but at the end of the day, they can't even be proud of what I have achieved in my adult life because they don't and can't understand what I do? Go figure. Sigh.
![]() |
| I was ruthlessly bludgeoned through the Singapore education system. |
Do you think it is possible for my parents to be proud of me even if they do not understand what it is I do? Is it possible to be proud of someone that way or is that just... impossible as you can't feel pride without knowing what you're proud of? Do your parents know what you do for a living? Have you found yourself in my position before? How can we resolve this huge generation gap? What can I do to try to bridge this gap? Please leave a comment below, many thanks.


I think the answer is yes. Your mom may not unferstand what you do, but she believes in you, and she knows you are successful in your life. She can see that you are independent and happy. Those are things to be proud of in your son.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your comment Di. I am not 100% confident that she believes in me - she was very against me studying in the UK, then she was very much against me working in the UK and she was again very much against me giving up my Singaporean nationality, but she couldn't stop me doing what I wanted to do anyway thanks to my dad.
DeleteLikewise, can she know that I am successful? Like how? I suppose if you were to look at the very material things, like how much money/wealth I have, then okay lah - in those terms, fair enough. I am independent and happy that she can see - but successful? Can she really appreciate that if she doesn't understand what I do? Can it only be seen through monetary terms? Like what must I do, buy her diamonds and pearls to prove to her that I can afford expensive gifts so she understands (in her most simple terms) that if I can afford expensive gifts then I am successful? Groan. I look at my friends and they just tell their parents what they have achieved and it's that straightfoward.
Yes, that may be how she gauges success. Material things. Don't be idealistic when it comes to parents their age. Otherwise you set yourself up for disappointment.
DeleteHello! the sheer fact that you're surviving well in the land of angmohs and that you can afford several trips back every now and then probably tells her that u're doing well.
ReplyDeleteI suppose for the older generation (a big generalization here) it's not a matter of how well or how high you fly, but rather to see that you're living a comfortable life and how happy you are.
For as long as u're happy and busy, I think she's proud that you're able to make yourself a good and comfortable living. Basic rubrics, basic happiness. If a person judges success by 100 marks, it doesn't matter if you score 100, 120 or 150 for that matter. or perhaps she's in denial of you working abroad as a FT?
Hi there - thanks for your comment.
DeleteSo what you're saying is they see it in very simple terms, ie. dollars & cents, wealth, do you own your own home, are you rich or poor?
That kinda disappoints me ... surely 'success' is far more complex in terms of what one achieves in one's career and it's not something that can be measured solely in terms of dollars & cents, n'est-ce pas? Or are we dealing with a generation who grew up in the 1940s and 1950s (my dad's born in 1938, my mum in 1943) where they barely had enough to eat, so they always default to money and wealth as a means to measure success?
Yes you're right, I believe their definition of success is pretty different because it's based on their own lifestyle and their own ambitions when they're growing up. Getting a degree in their time is a big deal, so getting a Masters, a PhD, or a professorial tenure is all the same: a big deal. So for that matter, she's proud of you.
ReplyDeleteShe'll always judge success based on her own experiences and her own yardsticks so don't worry too much about that la. It's really a generational and systematic gap judging how fast Singapore has industrialized and how much the education system has evolved.
Yeah I can see what you mean - allow me to give you an example. I have this old friend from my secondary school days I am still in touch with, let's call him Teo. Teo is very successful today as he has built up his own business from scratch, has invested his own money, carved a niche for himself and runs a successful company today doing something unique in Singapore. I have a LOT of respect for what Teo has achieved and I know how hard he has worked for his success today. My mother has met Teo and I have told her about Teo's success story and you know what? When I was in town last month, my mother said, "are you going to see your old friend Teo? You know, the one who drives a nice car?" And I'm like whaaaaaaaaat? Is that all you remember about Teo? That he drives a nice car? (A Lexus, hmmmm.) The fact that Teo drives a Lexus is almost like, so unimportant to me - it is more what he has achieved that I have respect for. But yeah, my mother sees the nice car = he must be doing well. When I try to explain to her what Teo does, it goes whooooosh right over her head, she doesn't understand (cos it's too internet-orientated, too modern, too complex etc).
DeleteHi. I'm a complete stranger commenting on your blog.
ReplyDeleteNo, my father does not know or care what I am doing. For that I am grateful, and I'm glad that we don't talk to each other at all.
You see, if I told him what I was doing, he'll find some way to smash it down.
A totally conceivable scenario:
Me: "But I'm trying to make my future better! Don't you understand? I'm trying to build something up, otherwise I'll be one of those who'll be used up and thrown away when I'm 45 or 50!"
Him: "Don't do it lah. You'll fail one lah. I heard about someone else on the street who failed doing similar things."
Then after that he'll spend day after day telling me how I'll fail, take up my time in saying that he's got much more life experience than me and things like that.
And on the day I give up, he'll be saying that I was sorely responsible for my decision and he had no hand in it.
Oddly enough, he's got no path for me to follow and he's not going to do anything to help me in anything.
So it's like I'm climbing a mountain, I'm hoping for at least a rope to pull myself up but all I get are rocks. It's like that since I started trying anything.
I still haven't gotten used to it though - I have a smidgen of a flicker of a hope that he'll say "Ok, I know you want to make it. I've seen you struggling, I've also seen that you've improved in your craft. What do you need? I trust you enough to give or lend you the resources you need."
But that's probably never going to happen. Someone wise said that humans are the most self rationalizing creatures on the planet. There'll always be another excuse, another reason, and later on I get rocks thrown at me.
And that's why it's much, much better if I don't communicate with my family at all. It's like giving them bullets when they've got an empty pistol.
Hi R2D2 and thanks for that heartfelt comment.
DeleteI guess compared to you, I have far less to complain about. But I guess the way I deal with it is to blame myself - my dad said something really hurtful the other day, I'm not going to go into it but I don't even think he realizes just how awful what he said was. He said it out of... sheer stupidity. Like what is the alternative? He said it out of spite? I don't think he cares enough about me to be motivated by spite, so sheer stupidity is the only other option.
So perhaps it is time for us both to lower our expectations to spare our feelings.
I guess you still want to have a relationship with your father, even if his social skills are lacking. I'm not an expert on that but I guess it's ok. Even with all the neglect and beating, you're going to have a relationship with your parents. Which some people might not do.
DeleteFor me once I'm able to earn enough money and do the things I'm good at, I'm out. I got no family attachments to tie me down - my father eroded all the respect I once had for him, and I'm not going to give up opportunities to become a somebody/an anybody.
But at the end of the day, I don't think either of us are that badly off. You're 35, you're a globetrotter, you seem to be doing investment banking or consulting work which pays well enough.
On the economic ladder I'm rungs way below you, and I got lots of areas to improve in. But at least I get to stay in a flat, I'm working on my abilities to make it without working for a boss, and there's some hope that I might get to where I want.
So.......life's ok compared to the starving kids in Ethiopia or the construction workers in China. Pity I didn't have your brains or drive when I was younger though - it might have made a lot of difference.
There is so much I wanna tell you but I can't as I have to dash for an 11 am meeting across town. I just wanna thank you for writing back and I will say more to you later.
DeleteHi, my story is rather similar to yours (though I’m way less materially successful). I’ve read a number of your entries, and I’m as similar as VJC + living in several countries can get.
ReplyDeleteBTW, it’s now 2015, so I don’t know if you have any insights on this issue, but I’d like to connect on this point ‘cos you’ve articulated the pain I had experienced before.
It sounds like you’re doing your best to understand your parents, but then your pain would come in, and start the questioning anew: why can’t they discuss intellectual or emotional topics with me?
Perhaps they have done their best, this is their best.
Perhaps their parents never sat them down to a conversation, and they don’t know how to open, sustain and close a conversation.
Maybe they were treated really badly in their childhood, and this is the best they can do. I suspect that’s true for many Chinese Singaporeans. Upon deeper conversation, I find that many of my friends’ family structures were very messed up either in their generation and/or their parents’ generation: womanizing fathers, physically abusive males, emotionally abused females, gambling etc. Trauma leaves an indelible impression upon the brain structure, and can permanently alter a person’s inclination for, say, joy, empathy, because they spent most of their time in fear, and their brains slowly pruned away (synaptic pruning) neural networks for other cognitive and emotional abilities. Your mom actually sounds a lot like mine and some other friends’, and I’ve always suspected an uncovered pattern of depression among women their generation. As for my dad, I came to realise he’s quite the reticent Chinese male expected to be stoic at all times. As I grew older, became more sensitive, I realized I can after all detect his fears and delights through certain statements.
And – I hope I won’t get flamed for this – I blame it on the national psychology shaped by our politicians, where bullying, posturing and aggression have driven out all passion, curiosity, emotional aliveness, ability to question and wonder from the citizens. I see it in people our age: “is it? I’ve never though about it”, “aiyah, why think so much?”, “no feeling”. A Gallup survey once showed Singaporeans are the most emotionless in the world. I mean, people our age are really young, but they are so worried about the consequences of emotions, which often make me think (without any scientific basis, I admit) about their fears leftover from seeing how Tang Liang Hong, Chee Soon Juan and other sharp-tongued individuals re characterized, and figured that the lack of emotions indicate a stoic and admirable temperament without realizing that dysthymia/apathy are worlds away from stoicism.
And why your mom wanna hold you back from going to other countries – again, I blame it on the national propaganda (please don’t let the Lional de Souzas find this post!). Even my friends of our age are convinced by the media that Singapore is so good, we “don’t have the freedom to get raped, to get shot” (near-direct quotes by those op-eds post-LKY death), and we’re often in the leagues tables for best country to live in/highest GDP etc, so even if life is shitty, it’s still less shitty than UK/Australia etc.
In addition, every country has its strengths and flaws – so foreign friends who are annoyed by the arrogance of the citizens or the state of human rights can still see the good sides of SG: less congestion than HK, vibrant budding tech start-up scene, ease of setting up business. So, what more the local who has family and the national media to convince them of so?
Good luck for all your ventures, and may you find peace :)
Hi Z. Thanks for your comment.
DeleteIt's 2015 now and I have drifted further and further away from my parents - I had achieved something that was quite a big deal (well, at least it mattered a lot to me, personally) late last year and I didn't even want to tell my parents because I just knew I was going to be disappointed by their lack of interest in me achieving the goals in my life because they simply do not take enough interest in what I get up to in Europe. So the situation is pretty much the same as it is today as when I first wrote this piece.
Do you know that in a recent study, I was revealed to be the joint 14th most read blogger in Singapore (why I was included in that list is a bit puzzling since I am based in London) - and if you strip out the blogs with more than one contributor, I shoot up to 8th place? I do pour my heart and soul out like this on my blog, dirty linen & all. I see some bloggers (social influencers, they call them) in Singapore who are pretty young ladies who just post pretty pictures of them in pretty dresses, pretty shoes and handbags and it's all, "look at me, I am so pretty, everything my life is so pretty, follow me and my pretty world on social media". I'm the total opposite: I'm a balding 39 year old man who pours his heart out on social media and talks about painful stuff and there's really very little about me that's pretty... So I am kinda amazed that in a place like Singapore, I can be ranked higher than a lot of these younger generation of super pretty young female bloggers when all I have are my thoughts and idea to offer and no pretty pictures of me looking ever so cute and pretty.
Many thanks for your support and please keep reading my blog.
... sorry one last point: I find it ironic that as an influential blogger (nearly 7 million views to date) my readers know so much more about me, about how I feel, about how I think, what motivates me, what excites me, what gets me angry or passionate etc, than my own parents. How ironic it is, that complete strangers can find out so much about me whilst my parents take zero interest in me, yet they were the ones who went through so much effort to bring me up? I just don't understand why you would want to commit to bringing a child only to wash your hands of him the moment he becomes an adult? Like i I was some kind of murderer or nasty evil person, then fair enough lah - but when I last checked, I have not done anything like that before. I am successful, rich and happy with my life - but I can't force my parents to want to keep me relevant in their lives.
DeleteHey, back again.
ReplyDeleteWhat if you remove your assumption that they know of several courses of action/had the power or capacity to choose, and replace that with: this is the best they know how to give?
Because of my background (not given adequate social skills), I myself committed many insensitivities. Now looking back, I feel incredibly guilty, but I know when I did those things, I didn’t know any better. I also understand that friends who I’d hurt would have looked at me: here’s an educated person. She did all this because she deliberately wanted to hurt me. She’s a mean person.