![]() |
| What does it mean to be mixed? |
He told me that my great grandfather was a Qing dynasty 官 (state official) in China and my great grandfather had two sons quite late in his life - one of whom (ie. my grandfather) moved to British-Malaya where he married my grandmother who was also Hakka. He didn't know anything beyond my great grandfather apart from some stories he heard about him in his childhood. "You see," he explained. "Your great grandfather, my grandfather, was in China whilst we grew up in Malaysia. We heard stories of course, but it was not like I ever met him. It's not like we could just get on a plane and go to China in those days, things were so different then. We're talking about the 1940s, 1950s..." He couldn't remember much about his mother's parents - but he said he knew they were Hakka but he couldn't remember if they were born in Malaya or China. She was betrothed to my grandfather from a very young age and didn't come from a rich family - so yeah, she did well in marrying a rich man.
Okay, so I got some information on my dad's side of the family but nothing to lead me any closer to my European roots - so I tried my mother. Her story is far more interesting. We started with my Hokkien maternal grandmother "Ah Jia" whom I knew well - Ah Jia was born in Singapore but her parents were born in China and had moved to Singapore before my grandmother was born. They were Hokkiens from near Amoy (Xiamen) and nope, absolutely no trace of anyone mixed or white. My mother was convinced, it wasn't her mother - there was just no way anyone on her side of the family could be anything but Hokkien.
![]() |
| How much of your family history do you actually know? |
I never got to know my maternal grandfather - my mother's father had passed away years before I was born. "What about your father then?" I asked my mother.
Woah. Please mum, tell me more. "He was... well, he was .... sold. Adopted is a nice word but back in those days, it wasn't uncommon to sell your children if you didn't have the means to care for them. This all happened back in China. He was sold as a baby to a richer family and they raised him - but from a young age, he was expected to work for them. He took their surname, learnt their language... He did all kinds of chores in their house and when they found themselves short on money when he was a teenager, they sold him off again."
"What?! Like a slave?" I asked. I was so shocked at the prospect of my grandfather having been sold as a slave! I remember hearing stories of his adoption in the past, but I didn't realize it wasn't adoption by our modern standards.
"No... well..." My mother struggled with her words. "Things were different then. If his biological parents hadn't sold him to that rich family, then he would've probably starved to death or had a very difficult life. He had no where to go, so if a rich family was willing to 'adopt' him - give him a roof over his head, feed him, clothe him in exchange for his labour as a child, then he was very lucky, you understand?"
![]() |
| My late Grandfather was "sold" as a labourer to a merchant in Singapore. |
She continued, "But things changed in that family and they found that they couldn't continue to 'keep' him as he got older. They just didn't have enough work for him to justify 'keeping' him, so he was sold again as a teenager. He was sold to a merchant looking to bring strong, young men to come to work in Singapore - he agreed to go to Singapore, it was not like he was sent there against his will. Anyway, that's how he ended up in Singapore. He worked very hard and repaid the debt for his passage to Singapore in a few years. That's when he met your grandmother and they married. You'd think that life got better for him, then the war (WW2) broke out and the Japanese invaded Singapore. I was a baby then, it was a long time ago. He became very sick during the war but never really recovered his health even after the war ended. That's when my older brother - your uncle - became the man of the family to take care of everyone in the family. Your uncle is a very great man."
I asked my mother, "Do you know where your father was from in China?"
![]() |
| Where is "Tua Bu Keh" in China??! Anyone? |
My mother paused and thought long and hard. "I cannot remember if I am saying this correctly ... tua3 (big?) bu3 (???) keh4 (???). I am probably pronouncing it wrongly, I cannot remember. I don't even know where it is, sorry. I can't even remember if that was where his adopted family was or where he was from originally. My father didn't like talking about his earlier life, he had such a hard life - he had his share of bad luck and just when you think everything was okay and he had finally found happiness the Japanese had to invade Singapore."
I don't know if I can assume that just because my maternal grandfather's past is unknown, that I could just assume that the European blood came in via him - but it is a possibility that even my mother acknowledged, though she added, "I suppose your grandfather looked Chinese...? Chinese people come in all shapes and forms, some taller, some shorter, some darker, some fairer. I suppose, even if he had Angmoh blood, it couldn't have been too much? We never suspected otherwise. He was raised by a Chinese family, so he felt Chinese, acted like a Chinese man, spoke Chinese... but as for his ancestors, his bloodline - we don't know and I guess we may never ever know. I don't even know where to start to find out, who to ask - people didn't keep records meticulously in those days you know? It's not like all the details of his biological parents are in some file somewhere in an office in China - there were probably no records and maybe even my father didn't know who his biological parents were."
So! It could be from my mother's side after all via my grandfather, but all I can say at this stage is that even my parents can't be totally sure as they don't know much beyond what happened in South East Asia - they know precious little about their ancestors in China and given that all four of my grandparents have now passed away, it will be very hard for me to try to find out more. "I suppose that'll remain a mystery for our family," my mother said.




Hi LIFT, I think rejecting your European DNA ancestry in favour of 'pure Chinese' is very racist.
ReplyDeleteHave you read about early human migrations?
Modern humans (Homos sapiens) ALL originated from Africa 200,000 years ago, reaching Europe 43,000 years ago and East Asia (that includes China) only 30,000 years ago.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_human_migrations
This means that, however proudly Chinese crow about our continuous 5,000 year history, we're ultimately African and there is a chance that we were European first before we became 'authentic' Chinese.
http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=File:Spreading_homo_sapiens.svg&page=1
After all, all of us living today are descended from one woman, who was the mother of all the mothers of all our mothers, Mitochondrial Eve:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mitochondrial_Eve
There is also a good chance that many Asian men trace their lineage back to the prolific Genghis Khan and his sons and their male descendanats, but would the Chinese ever honestly admit that?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genghis_khan#Descent
Unless of course we want to devotedly believe in the Chinese creation myth originating all the way back to Pangu 盘古 and Nüwa 女娲 , that humans are no more than mud drops shaken off a rope put through the water bed:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pangu#The_Panku_legend
I also had the chance to speak to my sister today and she was intrigued, curious and pretty open minded about the idea of us being mixed instead of 'pure Chinese'. The fact is, culturally, my sister and I are already both jiat-kentang in so many ways lah - so the fact that we turned out to be Eurasian just kinda feels right.
DeleteHowever, my dad doesn't speak English - yet it is probable that the angmoh blood came via him (well it's him or my mum) - he is the one who is totally rejecting the possibility of being Eurasian as it doesn't fit his cultural identity and experiences.
Thus for now, he is blanking it out whilst my sister and I are like totally embracing it.
Hi LIFT, This is super interesting. Incredible stuff! I expected a lot more comments on this, it just makes people want to rush out there & do a DNA test of their own. Maybe not that many people are posting because, well, its hard to give an opinion about this topic without someone or other leaping onto the term "racist". Alan, Im not referring to you saying "rejecting one's European roots is racist" because I know you are talking about LIFTs fathers reaction; the people I have in mind are the type who would accuse me of being racist if I tell LIFT "Congratulations, this is SUCH great news!" But, well, it IS, isnt it. Now you are truly a Man Of The World (at least 3 continents anyway) in every sense of the word. Migrating to the EU is like a homecoming for you!
ReplyDeleteYou know how when we were at school, we used to talk about our classmates like "Oh he's one-quarter Austalian, because his mother's father was from there" and things like that? If you look at it that way, having an angmo grandparent makes you 25% white, and a great-grandparent, 12.5%. Your percentage being in between, means you dont have to look beyond 3 generations of ancestors (counting upwards from your parents) to find the one who was an angmo, assuming your 15.8% comes predominantly from ONE of your ancestors and not a few of them. The probability that your maternal grandad was a 50%-50% Eurasian, is therefore very real. If your Mom remembers him, do ask whether she thinks he looked Eurasian, and does your Mom herself have any of those features (like a tall nose, as you pointed out about yourself)? Please keep us posted, thanks!
Hi Lam Toh,
DeleteI can tell you that upon analysis of the results (see the post here http://limpehft.blogspot.co.uk/2012/11/im-black-im-white-im-asian-am-i-panda.html) you would almost certainly have some European & African blood as well, it's just a question of proportion - I did manage to compare my sample to some other Asians (Chinese/Malay/Indonesian/Pakistani etc) - so yeah, everyone's a bit mixed and by that token, you're also a panda: ie. black, white & Asian :)
Here's the thing yeah, before I took the test, I never knew that I even had a drop of Angmoh blood - you should meet my parents, like I have the most traditional Chinese parents in Singapore (hence my dad's outright denial of the results despite the fact that the Angmoh DNA could've come via his side). My point is this: you can inherit DNA sure - it determines things like your height, your body type, your hair colour, your facial structure, eyes - maybe some things like natural athletic ability or talent for music ... then there's so much more that we acquire after birth through hard work - nature vs nurture.
It is a bit simplistic (I was told) to assume that 50/25/12.5/etc division in terms of DNA - since it is not an exact science which parent we get our DNA from. At the point of conception, you have 2 gene pools to choose from: mom & dad and there's all these things about the dominant gene getting through etc ... complex science. Besides, I cannot assume that it must DEFINITELY be my maternal grandfather who is 50-50 mixed, because we know very little about my dad's mother as well.
I didn't wanna write this in my main article cos I am scared of pissing my dad off but I will write it here. My grandfather's family is very rich and my dad's mother was from a poor family but was betrothed to my grandfather at the age of about 12/13 because of her good looks. It is very rare for a rich family to accept a bride/arranged marriage with someone from a poor family like that, but it was like, they were walking through the market place and my grandfather literally picked her out in the crowd and said, "that girl there, she is beautiful, she is special, can we buy her? We have so much money, we are rich, tell her parents to name their price."
Sure enough my grandmother was from a poor family and they gladly 'betrothed' her (which is another nice word for 'sold' her for a tidy sum of money, oh they call that a 'dowry') to my dad's family despite the fact that at 12/13 she was too young to marry him yet. From what I learnt, my grandmother didn't complain as she went from a poor family to a rich family and hey, life was hard back then and it was nice having money and servants. She never spoke much about her background because she was ashamed of being the poorer daughter-in-law who married into a rich family. For whatever reason, my dad never tried to get more info out of her, apart from what info she volunteered.
Now there is a possibility that my grandmother had a bit of mixed blood in her to give her some element of exotic looks, which set her apart from the crowd, so my grandfather could literally pick her out in the crowd like that, so struck by her beauty. Of course, my dad would shoot that theory down - he would tell you that Chinese people can be 100% Chinese and still be beautiful, that we don't need Angmoh DNA to make us beautiful. It's all stories I was told lah, I think my grandmother was also prone to bragging, ie., "oh you may see an old lady before you now, but did you know just how stunningly beautiful I was when I was younger...? The moment your grandfather saw me he was so struck by my unique beauty he couldn't take his eyes off me and simply had to have me, it was love at first sight... That was just how incredibly beautiful I was... I was the most beautiful girl in the whole town!" Yeah you were like 12 and that makes it all wrong on so many levels (by our modern standards at least).
Part 2: So - out of my 4 grandparents, I know precious little about 2 of them. One refused to talk about it and the other was adopted as a baby. So maybe one of them is mixed or both of them were mixed ... who knows? Sadly, unfortunately, all my grandparents have passed away already, so I guess we will never know - but there is the possibility that both my parents have a bit of Eurasian blood and they're both around the 15% mark ... rather than for this to have been passed down from one parent (and not the other).
DeleteMy parents told me that my maternal grandfather didn't stand out as Eurasian ... I have seen one old photograph of him and he did look Chinese. My mum looks very Chinese herself - so that is why they are surprised. At the end of the day, 15.8% isn't much lah, it's probably only slightly more than what most Chinese would have anyway. In comparison with other Asians, they usually carry anything like 1-2 up to 7-8% Angmoh blood anyway, I'm just slightly (ever so slightly) above the average.
Oh yeah, another pic of my big nose here http://limpehft.blogspot.co.uk/2012/10/what-difference-15-years-makes.html I never ever thought anything about having a big nose you know... I just thought, yeah faces come in all shapes & forms ... I was ever teased for having a big nose when I was a kid in primary school! There were some rather rude things the kids use to say about my nose in Hokkien - erm, which I shall not repeat here.
Deleteahem, you are making some assumptions when discussing this, in particular with regards to lineage. (in other words, type your parents' DNA too to check relationship!)
ReplyDeleteWhat do you mean "type your parents' DNA too to check relationship"? I hate to be the English teacher here, but you're not being clear in your sentence about what you want me to do? Can you kindly clarify please? I can't figure out what the hell you're trying to say?
DeleteIf you mean you want me to get my parents to take some form of DNA analysis, then sure - though I can probably persuade my mother but my father is so appalled by the idea of being anything but "pure Chinese" (he is a VERY racist person) that I would never be able to persuade him to do this, as he would rather believe what he wants to believe rather than find out about the truth about his lineage.
If you are questioning if I was adopted, then I can tell you that my parents did confirm that I wasn't adopted.
In any case, there is no such thing as "pure Chinese" - everyone is a bit mixed; such was the purpose of this test, it was to prove that everyone shares that aspect of being mixed. Different people from different countries are mixed in different ways, but we are all mixed - see diagrams here: http://limpehft.blogspot.co.uk/2012/11/im-black-im-white-im-asian-am-i-panda.html
Hi, I saw "tua3 (big?) bu3 (???) keh4 (???)" and the first thing that came to my mind was this: 大埔客。客 as in 客家人. 大埔 (Dapu) being a county in Guangdong that many Hakkas in Singapore originally came from (like my paternal grandfather). My guess could be totally way off, but just thought I'd share anyway.
ReplyDeleteHi Lyn, thanks for your comment. I will look into this!
Delete